Copa Aldao

Copa Ricardo Aldao
	The trophy awarded to champions
Organising body	AFA; AUF
Founded	1913
Abolished	1955; 69 years ago
Region	Buenos Aires, Argentina; Montevideo, Uruguay
Number of teams	2
Related competitions	Copa Campeonato del Río de la Plata
Last champions	River Plate (1947)
Most successful club(s)	River Plate ; (5 titles)

The Copa Ricardo Aldao (English: Ricardo Aldao Cup), popularly called Campeonato Rioplatense and Copa Río de La Plata, was an official AFA-AUF football club competition contested annually, albeit irregularly, between the league champions of Argentina and Uruguay. The trophy was donated by Argentine football executive Ricardo Aldao (1863–1956), who would later become president of the Argentine Football Association.

The cup is one of several inter-South American club competitions that have been organised on the continent. The first competition was scheduled for the 1913 season (although it was never played) and the last in 1955 (actually played in 1959, no champions proclaimed). The Copa Ricardo Aldao is seen today as the first stepping-stone toward the creation of the Copa Libertadores.^[1] In 2009, when the IFFHS proclaimed Peñarol of Montevideo as the best South American team of the 20th century, they took into consideration the Copa Aldao and other international club tournaments played in South America before the beginning of Copa Libertadores in 1960.^[2]

In August 2015, a CONMEBOL's article described Aldao Cup as one of the first international professional football cups in South America.^[3]

Many important footballers played in the competitions such as the Argentines Jose Manuel Moreno, Angel Labruna, Guillermo Stabile, Alfredo Di Stefano, Adolfo Pedernera, Amadeo Carrizo, Carlos Peucelle, Felix Loustau, Nestor Rossi, Antonio Sastre, Bernardo Gandulla, the Italian-born Renato Cesarini, the Uruguayans Roque Máspoli, Ángel Romano, Obdulio Varela, Hector Scarone, Juan Alberto Schiaffino, Anibal Paz, Severino Varela, and Paraguayan legend Arsenio Erico, among others.

History

Friendly matches were common between clubs from Argentina and Uruguay in the early 1900s due to the close proximity of the nations. Inevitably, a match to decide which national champions were the best formulated; the trophy of the competition was donated by Ricardo Aldao, then president of both, club Gimnasia y Esgrima (BA) and dissident association "Federación Argentina de Football". As such, the competition was named after his donation. The first edition, organized in 1913, was to be contested between Estudiantes from Argentina and River Plate from Uruguay. However, the match was suspended due to heavy rain and never rescheduled.^[4] The first champion of the competition was not crowned until 1916, when Nacional of Montevideo beat Racing de Avellaneda 2–1.

Originally, a single-legged format was adopted, with the match played in Argentina and Uruguay in alternative year.^[4] But in 1940, Boca Juniors left the field when the match, played at Montevideo, was at a draw of 2–2 and headed for extra-time. The title was awarded to Nacional at first, yet later on both associations did not defined clearly the champions of this year.^[4] Asociación Uruguaya de Fútbol (AUF) and Argentine Football Association (AFA) studied the situation on 22 January 1941, and announced that a two-legged format would be adopted in the following seasons.^[4] The finals should be disputed before the beginning of the next season. Only players that had been part of the domestic champion squads could be included.^[5] Since then, the competition was played two-legged exception made of the 1942 edition, when the second leg was not played and the trophy was not awarded.

Schedule problems forced teams of both countries to quit the Aldao Cup during the 1950s,^[3] thus the competition was discontinued until 1959. One last attempt was made to rekindle the championship in 1955 in a match between Nacional and River Plate. However, the final was not disputed until four years later and the second leg was never played; therefore, the title was not officially proclaimed.^[4] As a result, to the schedule congestion of the growing national leagues (as well as the creation of the new continental club tournament, the Copa Libertadores de América) the Copa Aldao became redundant and was never played again.

List of champions

Finals

Below is a list with all the finals played. Since 1941, it was ruled that the cup would be defined in two legs.^[4]

Keys

Playoff result
Since 1941, the cup was played under a two-legged format (with no goal difference)

Ed.	Year	Champion	Score	Runner-up	Venue	City
1	1913	(abandoned) ^{[n 1]}
2	1916	Nacional (1)	2–1	Racing	GEBA	Buenos Aires
3	1917	Racing (1)	2–2	Nacional	Parque Pereira	Montevideo
3	1917	Racing (1)	2–1 ^{[n 2]}	Nacional	GEBA	Buenos Aires
4	1918	Racing (2)	2–1	Peñarol	GEBA	Buenos Aires
5	1919	Nacional (2)	3–0	Boca Juniors	Parque Central	Montevideo
6	1920	Nacional (3)	2–1	Boca Juniors	Sp. Barracas	Buenos Aires
–	1923	(not held) ^{[n 3]}
7	1927	San Lorenzo (1)	1–0	Rampla Juniors	Parque Central	Montevideo
8	1928	Peñarol (1)	3–0	Huracán	River Plate	Buenos Aires
9	1936	River Plate (1)	5–1	Peñarol	Centenario	Montevideo
10	1937	River Plate (2)	5–2	Peñarol	San Lorenzo	Buenos Aires
11	1938	Independiente (1)	3–1	Peñarol	Centenario	Montevideo
12	1939	Independiente (2)	5–0	Nacional	San Lorenzo	Buenos Aires
13	1940	(no champion crowned) ^{[n 4]}	2–2	–	Centenario	Montevideo
14	1941	River Plate (3)	6–1	Nacional	San Lorenzo	Buenos Aires
14	1941	River Plate (3)	1–1	Nacional	Centenario	Montevideo
15	1942	(no champion crowned) ^{[n 5]}	4–0	–	Centenario	Montevideo
16	1945	River Plate (4)	2–1	Peñarol	Centenario	Montevideo
16	1945	River Plate (4)	3–2	Peñarol	San Lorenzo	Buenos Aires
–	1946	(not held) ^{[n 6]}
17	1947	River Plate (5)	4–3	Nacional	Centenario	Montevideo
17	1947	River Plate (5)	3–1	Nacional	San Lorenzo	Buenos Aires
18	1957	(no champion crowned) ^{[n 7]}	2–1	–	Centenario	Montevideo

Notes

^ Argentine historian Miguel Bionda (in his book Historia del Fútbol Platense) asserts that the 1913 edition was indeed played and Estudiantes de La Plata defeated Uruguayan River Plate 4–1. Likewise, the magazines Estudiantes del Mundo: 100 años de gloria, published by Argentine newspaper El Día in 2005, and the book Historia de Estudiantes de La Plata, edited by Diario Hoy in 1997 agreed with that. On the other hand, other sources, like the RSSSF and the Centro para la Investigación de la Historia del Fútbol state that the game was suspended due to rain.^[4]
^ Not a second leg but a playoff match to determine a champion.
^ Replaced by a match between San Lorenzo and Wandereres named "Copa Campeonato del Río de la Plata" (San Lorenzo won 1–0). Both clubs belonged to dissident associations so it was not a "Copa Aldao" edition.^[4]
^ Nacional and Boca Juniors played a match at Estadio Centenario on 28 December 1940 which ended in a 2–2 draw. Boca Juniors left the field before the extra time, then the cup was initially awarded to Nacional, but eventually neither association designated a champion.^[4]^[6]
^ Nacional beat River Plate 4–0 in the first leg played at Montevideo, but the cup was never officially awarded as the second leg was never disputed.^[4]
^ Replaced by two friendly matches between both finalists (Nacional and San Lorenzo).^[4]
^ River Plate defeated Nacional 2–1 in the first leg played at Montevideo, but the cup was never officially awarded as the second leg was never disputed.^[4]

Titles by club

Team	Titles	Years won
River Plate	5	1936, 1937, 1941, 1945, 1947
Nacional	3	1916, 1919, 1920
Independiente	2	1938, 1939
Racing	2	1917, 1918
Peñarol	1	1928
San Lorenzo	1	1927

Titles by country

Country	Titles	Winner teams
Argentina	10	River Plate (5), Racing (2), Independiente (2), San Lorenzo (1)
Uruguay	4	Nacional (3), Peñarol (1)

All-time top scorers

Player	Goals	Club
Ángel Labruna	12	River Plate
Atilio García	8	Nacional
Adolfo Pedernera	4	River Plate
Arsenio Erico	4	Independiente
Ángel Romano	4	Nacional
Hugo Reyes	4	River Plate

Most finals by player

6: Atilio García (won 2), Anibal Paz (won 2)
5: Hector Scarone (won 4), José Manuel Moreno (won 4)
4: Angel Labruna (won 3), Alfredo Foglino (won3), Ricardo Vaghi (won 3), Adolfo Pedernera (won 3), Felix Loustau (won 3), Angel Romano (won 3), Roberto Porta (won 1),
3: Alberto Marcovecchio (won 3), Carlos Peucelle (won 3), Carlos Scarone (won 2), Hector Castro (won 1), Severino Varela (won 0)

References

^ La madre de la Copa Libertadores on Pasión Fútbol, 9 Aug 2013
^ "Peñarol chosen as the South American club of the century". Buenos Aires Herald. 17 September 2009. Archived from the original on 2 April 2015. Retrieved 24 March 2015.
^ ^a ^b River Plate, ensancha sus vitrinas para seguir sumando copas Archived 2019-04-02 at the Wayback Machine on Conmebol, 16 Aug 2015
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g ^h ⁱ ^j ^k ^l Campeonato Rioplatense - Copa Dr. Ricardo C. Aldao Archived 2012-09-03 at the Wayback Machine on RSSSF
^ "Memoria y Balance 1941 - pp. 45-46". AFA. Archived from the original on 6 March 2016. Retrieved 10 May 2015.
^ "La copa internacional que Boca perdió por abandonar" Archived 2021-02-28 at the Wayback Machine on Infobae, 19 August 2019 (in Spanish)

[sources-6] Argentine historian Miguel Bionda (in his book Historia del Fútbol Platense) asserts that the 1913 edition was indeed played and Estudiantes de La Plata defeated Uruguayan River Plate 4–1. Likewise, the magazines Estudiantes del Mundo: 100 años de gloria, published by Argentine newspaper El Día in 2005, and the book Historia de Estudiantes de La Plata, edited by Diario Hoy in 1997 agreed with that. On the other hand, other sources, like the RSSSF and the Centro para la Investigación de la Historia del Fútbol state that the game was suspended due to rain.^[4]

[noleg-7] Not a second leg but a playoff match to determine a champion.

[dissid-8] Replaced by a match between San Lorenzo and Wandereres named "Copa Campeonato del Río de la Plata" (San Lorenzo won 1–0). Both clubs belonged to dissident associations so it was not a "Copa Aldao" edition.^[4]

[left-10] Nacional and Boca Juniors played a match at Estadio Centenario on 28 December 1940 which ended in a 2–2 draw. Boca Juniors left the field before the extra time, then the cup was initially awarded to Nacional, but eventually neither association designated a champion.^[4]^[6]

[no2legs-11] Nacional beat River Plate 4–0 in the first leg played at Montevideo, but the cup was never officially awarded as the second leg was never disputed.^[4]

[unoff-12] Replaced by two friendly matches between both finalists (Nacional and San Lorenzo).^[4]

[noriver2-13] River Plate defeated Nacional 2–1 in the first leg played at Montevideo, but the cup was never officially awarded as the second leg was never disputed.^[4]

[1] La madre de la Copa Libertadores on Pasión Fútbol, 9 Aug 2013

[2] "Peñarol chosen as the South American club of the century". Buenos Aires Herald. 17 September 2009. Archived from the original on 2 April 2015. Retrieved 24 March 2015.

[ensancha-3] River Plate, ensancha sus vitrinas para seguir sumando copas Archived 2019-04-02 at the Wayback Machine on Conmebol, 16 Aug 2015

[rsssf-4] ^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g ^h ⁱ ^j ^k ^l Campeonato Rioplatense - Copa Dr. Ricardo C. Aldao Archived 2012-09-03 at the Wayback Machine on RSSSF

[5] "Memoria y Balance 1941 - pp. 45-46". AFA. Archived from the original on 6 March 2016. Retrieved 10 May 2015.

[9] "La copa internacional que Boca perdió por abandonar" Archived 2021-02-28 at the Wayback Machine on Infobae, 19 August 2019 (in Spanish)

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[n 1]

[n 2]

[n 3]

[n 4]

[n 5]

[n 6]

[n 7]

[6]

v t e Non-CONMEBOL South American official competitions
AFA / AUF	Tie Cup (1900–19) Copa de Honor Cousenier (1905–20) Copa Aldao (1913–55) Copa Escobar-Gerona (1941–46)
AAmF / FUF	Copa Campeonato Río de la Plata (1923)
FVF	Copa Simón Bolívar (1970–76)